Court throws out Thruway Authority lawsuit over faulty wind turbines 

Eight years after spending $5 million to install wind turbines at four highway exits in Western New York – and five years after they stopped working – the state Thruway Authority has lost its bid to hold five installation contractors accountable, after a state judge threw out its lawsuit.

State Supreme Court Justice Richard M. Platkin in Albany dismissed the 4-year-old lawsuit against CHA Consulting, Kandey Company, Vergnet S.A., Ravi Engineering and Land Surveying PC, and Prudent Engineering. He said the state waited 40 days too long to sue one of them, and also failed to demonstrate that the defendants were responsible for the equipment problems under their contracts with the Thruway Authority.

“The Court is unpersuaded by NYSTA’s arguments,” Platkin wrote, referring to the Thruway Authority.

The Thruway Authority had alleged negligence, professional malpractice, breach of warranty and breach of contract, as it sought to recoup $8.1 million in damages from the turbine equipment manufacturer, Vergnet, and from the contractor and consultants who installed the two-blade machines in four locations. It argued that the machines did not perform as promised after they went offline between October 2017 and January 2018.

But after 18 months of evidence discovery and motions, the judge agreed with the defendants that the state had failed to take into account the impact of wind speed and intensity in those locations, which was as much as twice what Vergnet’s site assessment had assumed, and what the company effectively warranted prior to the installation.

While implying that CHA may have had some responsibility, the judge also said the statute of limitations had expired on the state’s claims against CHA, making that portion of the case moot. Platkin also dismissed various cross-claims filed by the firms against each other.

“Bottom line here is that the state did not do its due diligence in testing the winds to make sure the wind turbines they picked could stand up to the winds,” said attorney Joseph J. Manna of Lipsitz Green Scime Cambria, representing West Seneca-based Kandey, the prime contractor on the project. “CHA was supposed to do that testing, but the state waited too long to sue CHA.”

State officials have not yet decided whether to appeal.

“We are disappointed in the judge’s decision to dismiss the case,” said Thruway Authority spokesman Jonathan Dougherty. ” We are reviewing the details of the decision and will determine our next steps.”

The Thruway Authority hired the companies to install the wind turbines in 2013-2014 as part of a renewable-energy program designed to generate enough power to save the authority as much as $420,000 a year on energy bills. The equipment was put up on authority-owned property in Erie and Chautauqua counties, at Exits 57A, 58, 59 and 61.

The authority spent $500,000 on design and up to $4.8 million on installation, which was completed in 2015. But the machines stopped working within two years because of mechanical issues, drawing significant attention and criticism, and prompting the state’s lawsuit in November 2018.

Albany-based CHA – formerly Clough Harbour & Associates – served as the design engineer for the project, providing preliminary engineering, final design and construction support. Kandey was the prime contractor, selected through a competitive bidding process, and it hired France’s Vergnet, which manufactured the machines. Syracuse-based Prudent served as onsite inspection engineer, and subcontracted some inspection work to Ravi.